HOME >Our action >Journalism

The media’s role in fostering interfaith ties in Indonesia

Wednesday 7 October 2015, by SIGNIS

Djakarta, Brussels, October 7th, 2015 (The Jakarta Post/ Endy M. Bayuni/SIGNIS) The senior editor of The Jakarta Post Endy M. Bayuni notes that Indonesia celebrates this year its 70th anniversary not only of its independence, but also of its diversity.

To him it is astonishing how more than 250 million people, made up of different races, ethnicities, cultures, traditions, languages and faiths, have survived as one nation for seven decades. He knows it hasn’t been easy, with trials and tribulations. His observation about multiculturalism and interfaith is really interesting and fits in the interest SIGNIS has in interfaith and media.

Catholic daily Kompas

Bayyni notes that this year, Kompas , the Indonesia’s largest national daily newspaper launched by a Catholic foundation, celebrates its 50th anniversary. Nothing in the paper’s appearance suggests that it caters to a specific religious community. Kompas reaches out to the wider public, and not just the tiny Roman Catholic community in Indonesia. Its founders made a conscious decision to produce a newspaper that transcends the religious divide in Indonesia, the country with the world’s largest Muslim population. It simply practices good journalism.

Not many specific religious Newspapers

There are other newspapers that cater to specific religious communities, Muslims and Christians, but they are not as widely read. Indonesia’s news industry is dominated by publications that cater to the general audience rather than specific religious groups. The same goes for private broadcasters, television and radio stations.
We should not understate the role of the media in bridging Indonesia’s racial, ethnical and religious divisions. There are countries in Asia that are racially and ethnically divided, where each community reads from its own newspaper. Such media outlets would not only represent the interests of the community, but often they would sharpen differences and perpetuate tensions and conflicts.

Media organizations have the power to divide or unite societies.

The Asian news industry has shown that good journalism in the name of public services can help promote peaceful coexistence and greater tolerance between religious communities. This may go against the industry’s popular adage that “bad news is good news, and that good news is no news”, but those managing the news industry know that if society is in conflict, the media will lose and suffer just as much, because it is part of society. It has a stake in society’s well-being and must take responsibility in helping to promote peace and harmony.

Media reporting about religion and about Indonesia’s religious communities is by no means perfect. It can improve much more in promoting peace, especially amid rising religious tension, harassment and persecution, and rising religious intolerance. The rise of the Internet and social media in disseminating news and information has made the task more complex. With the fierce competition to be the first, online media often sacrifices accuracy.

Catholic media reporters

The media fell short of its standards in reporting the Tolikara tragedy in July, when Christians and Muslims clashed in a remote town in Papua. Journalists had difficulties in getting access to the story (a five-hour ride by car from the nearest biggest town), so they relied on information fed by sources on the ground that were part of the conflict and were reporting only partially, not wholly.

The media in Indonesia is still divided about how to handle religious conflicts; mindful that on how they report, they would affect public opinion and could inflame tensions. Some newspapers avoid reporting them completely; others bury the stories inside; and some others blur the religious identities. But some would go to the other extreme, and report the stories in full; some would intentionally use inflaming terms.
The media is obliged to report all these tensions and conflicts. It should not withhold any information, but should exercise care and wisdom in reporting them and not fuel the tensions. Under president and Dictator Suharto, who ruled from 1967 to 1998, the media had specific instructions not to report stories of religious tensions and conflicts.

Today it is left to the discretion of editors to decide whether to report religious tensions and conflicts, and how they want to cover them.

Media’s role influencing public opinion

Since the media’s main role is to influence public opinion, it is the “cheerleader” in interfaith relations and dialogue. The media can sway public opinion toward peace or conflict or war. As the fourth pillar of democracy, the media should hold the government accountable for ensuring religious freedom and for protecting the rights of religious communities, including their right to build places of worship and to practice their faith.

Media outlets can at least help reduce prevailing ignorance between religious communities, by reporting more about the lives and the beliefs of the different communities they serve. Ignorance, the chief source of mutual suspicion and intolerance, allows extremist elements in all religions to exploit the fear.
Media outlets need to build their own tradition of reporting better about the faiths and the religious communities in their respective societies, avoid malicious stereotyping and perpetuating prejudices that one group has about the other. The media needs to give more space to the voices of moderation that speak of peace and less to the fear-mongering radical and extremist groups.

In societies where people build their lives around observation of religious rituals, as in Indonesia, the media must do a better job in reflecting this reality – and not only report about religion when there are tensions or conflicts. The media would do a much better job in covering society if newsroom staff reflected as much as possible the ethnical, racial and religious diversity. Finally, by practicing good journalism, the media would help to build better understanding between religious communities. It can encourage religious communities to collaborate and work together in addressing common challenges.

Subscribe to our Newsletter
SIGNIS in the world
Choose your organization in the world.