englishespagñolfrançais
Cinema - Reviews
print the article


Related articles
  1. Adventures in Zambezia
  2. Antiviral
  3. Chasing Ice
  4. Cheerful Weather for the Wedding
  5. The Company You Keep
  6. Drift
  7. Escape from Planet Earth
  8. First Position
  9. Haute Cuisine/ Les Saveurs de Palais
  10. Identity Thief
  11. Iron Man 3
  12. No
  13. Oblivion
  14. Olympus Has Fallen
  15. The Other Son/ Le Fils de L’Autre
  16. The Place Beyond the Pines
  17. Rust and Bone
  18. Le Skylab
  19. Sleepwalk with Me
  20. Song for Marion
  21. Therese Desqueyroux
  22. Trance
  23. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlinale 2013
  24. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February 2013
  25. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2012
  26. "Aristides de Sousa Mendes": The Angel of Bordeaux
  27. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2012
  28. SIGNIS Film Reviews: July/August 2012
  29. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June 2012
  30. SIGNIS Film Reviews: May 2012
  31. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March 2012
  32. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2012 Special Edition
  33. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2012
  34. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October/November 2011
  35. SIGNIS Film Reviews: May/June 2011
  36. SIGNIS Statement: Oranges and Sunshine
  37. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March/April 2011
  38. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlinale 2011 Special Edition
  39. SIGNIS Statement: The Rite
  40. SIGNIS Statement: Brighton Rock
  41. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2011
  42. Out Of The Silence
  43. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2010
  44. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October/November 2010
  45. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2010
  46. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Summer 2010
  47. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2010 Special Edition
  48. SIGNIS Statement: "Des hommes et des dieux" (Of Gods and Men)
  49. SIGNIS Film Reviews: April/May 2010
  50. SIGNIS Statement: Agora
  51. SIGNIS Statement: The Calling
  52. SIGNIS Statement: Lourdes
  53. SIGNIS Statement: No Greater Love
  54. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2010 Special Edition
  55. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January/February 2010
  56. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October/November/December 2009
  57. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Summer 2009
  58. Antichrist: An Essay/Review
  59. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2009 Special Edition
  60. SIGNIS Statement: Angels and Demons
  61. SIGNIS Film Reviews: April 2009
  62. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March 2009
  63. SIGNIS Statement: Religulous
  64. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2009 Special Edition
  65. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February 2009
  66. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2009
  67. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2008
  68. The Church in Transition: Doubt
  69. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October-November 2008
  70. SIGNIS Statement: Brideshead Revisited and its Catholicism
  71. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2008
  72. SIGNIS Film reviews: August 2008
  73. SIGNIS Statement: The X-Files: I Want to Believe
  74. SIGNIS Film Reviews: July 2008
  75. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June 2008
  76. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2008 Special Edition
  77. SIGNIS Films Reviews: April 2008
  78. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March 2008
  79. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2008 Special Edition
  80. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February 2008
  81. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2008
  82. SIGNIS Statement: The Golden Compass
  83. SIGNIS Film Reviews: November 2007
  84. SIGNIS Statement: Elizabeth - The Golden Age
  85. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October 2007
  86. SIGNIS Films Reviews: August/September 2007
  87. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June-July 2007
  88. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
  89. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2007 Special Edition
  90. SIGNIS Film Reviews: May 2007
  91. SIGNIS Film Reviews: April 2007
  92. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February/March 2007
  93. Deliver Us from Evil: SIGNIS Statement
  94. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2007
  95. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2006
  96. SIGNIS Film Reviews: November 2006
  97. The Nativity Story
  98. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October 2006
  99. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2006
  100. SIGNIS Film Reviews: August 2006
  101. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June/July 2006
  102. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2006 Special Edition
  103. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, MARCH 2006, SUPPLEMENT
  104. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, MARCH 2006
  105. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, FEBRUARY 2006
  106. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, JANUARY 2006

Perfume: the Story of a Murderer

(JPEG) (Germany, 2006. d. Tom Tykwer)

Perfume is a skilful adaptation of a celebrated novel by Patrick Suskind who is said to have resisted the idea of making a film of his book - which many considered to be unfilmable. Now director Tom Tykwer (Run, Lola, Run, Princess and the Warrior, Heaven) in collaboration with British writer-director, Andrew Birkin, and German producer Bernd Eichenger have filmed the unfilmable.

One of the reasons for declaring that the novel could not be filmed was that it is about a sense that does not lend itself to cinema (except by means of a gimmick): the sense of smell. However, Tykwer rightly stated that a printed book is not a medium for smell either. The communication is in the writing and its evocations. So, for a film, the evocation is in the images.

Perfume is primarily about smell and touch, much less so about sight and hearing, though they are not, of course, irrelevant to the film. Rather, the evocation of audience imagination is by suggestion through sight and hearing. Film lecturers talk about the camera and ‘point of view’. In Perfume, the audience is offered the central character’s ‘point of scent’.

Before considering how Tykwer communicates this experience of scent and smell on the part of Jean Baptiste, it is necessary to focus on who that character is. It is Paris in the 18th century, the most populated city in Europe, a city which, so the elegant narration (from the prose of the novel) by John Hurt reminds us, stank. Personal hygiene, urban garbage and pollution, the welcome as well as noisome odours from places like the fish market meant a distinctive and sometimes overwhelming aroma. (The word choice available to suggest this already has its limitations: smell, odour, scent, aroma and, of course, perfume.)

Perfume is what motivates Jean Baptiste, an unwanted baby born under a counter amongst the fish waste as his mother took some minutes off from her work. Growing up in an orphanage, he became more and more aware of his giftedness, his ability to detect and relish a vast variety of odours. After working in a tannery for years during his adolescence, he has the opportunity to come across some tantalising and beautiful odours amongst the rich and Parisian society: perfumes. Perfume becomes the be-all and end-all (literally) of his life.

It can be said, without spoiling the plot, that we know from the opening of the film (where Tykwer immediately limits our vision with darkness and silhouette but focuses on an inhaling nose) that Jean Baptiste has been accused of murder and is to be tortured and executed, to the delight of a crowd baying for blood and vengeance.

Then the flashback to his birth and the narration. The first half of the film then shows how Jean Baptiste impressed an ageing and out-of-date perfume creator and becomes an expert in recipes for perfumes that become the talk of Paris. The old man is played with some relish (and some peculiar variations of broken Italian and American accents) by Dustin Hoffman.

It is in this context that Jean Baptiste, fascinated by a young serving woman wearing a perfume, kills his first victim. He does not want to murder her but to keep her quiet. He strangles her. But, Jean Baptiste has very little moral sense and is not much bothered by what he has done.

The second half of the film has him go to Grasse, a perfume-making town in Provence where fields of lavender and other plants are cultivated. After demonstrating his skills, he is employed there but he has become obsessed with creating the perfect perfume - which are made from the personal odours of beautiful women. Thus, he begins a hidden and solitary career as a serial killer. The culminating victim is to be the beautiful daughter of the lord of the local manor (Alan Rickman).

While he pursues his goals, the audience focuses on a version of an 18th century panic, hysteria, the attempt to cope with a serial killer in a village and the investigation. Finally, there is an execution scene which takes us from reality and goes into the mind and imagination of Jean Baptiste: everybody understands what he has done, asks his pardon and are so influenced by his perfect perfume that they love everyone near them, throw off inhibitions and clothes and indulge in a love-in (which might have made Ken Russell in his heyday rather jealous).

The running time of the film is quite long, almost two and a half hours. For those not drawn into the themes and the pace of the film, it will seem very long indeed and give them time to disapprove and even think the film and its style pretentious. For those attracted and intrigued by theme and treatment, the length will not matter too much as they have entered into another world, into the 18th century settings, into the mind and morbid imagination of Jean Baptiste as well as the fears of the society he has intimidated.

But, most of all, this audience will have been seduced, sometimes subtly, sometimes obviously, by the visual evocation of so many smell experiences, a range of odours from the vile to the exquisite, that are the idiosyncratic experiences of Jean Baptiste. That is the skill of the screenplay, of Tykwer’s directing style and the editing and the performance of Ben Wishaw who, with his skinny build and air of being perpetually put upon, has chosen to make his character something of a ‘tabula rasa’, someone who passively absorbs rather than being proactive (except for his grotesque series of murders and his bizarre methods of using animal fats to absorb the essence of his victims).

Tom Tykwer has every reason to be pleased with and proud of Perfume: the Story of a Murderer.

Peter Malone

print the article