englishespagñolfrançais
Cinema - Reviews
print the article


Related articles
  1. Adventures in Zambezia
  2. Antiviral
  3. Chasing Ice
  4. Cheerful Weather for the Wedding
  5. The Company You Keep
  6. Drift
  7. Escape from Planet Earth
  8. First Position
  9. Haute Cuisine/ Les Saveurs de Palais
  10. Identity Thief
  11. Iron Man 3
  12. No
  13. Oblivion
  14. Olympus Has Fallen
  15. The Other Son/ Le Fils de L’Autre
  16. The Place Beyond the Pines
  17. Rust and Bone
  18. Le Skylab
  19. Sleepwalk with Me
  20. Song for Marion
  21. Therese Desqueyroux
  22. Trance
  23. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlinale 2013
  24. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February 2013
  25. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2012
  26. "Aristides de Sousa Mendes": The Angel of Bordeaux
  27. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2012
  28. SIGNIS Film Reviews: July/August 2012
  29. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June 2012
  30. SIGNIS Film Reviews: May 2012
  31. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March 2012
  32. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2012 Special Edition
  33. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2012
  34. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October/November 2011
  35. SIGNIS Film Reviews: May/June 2011
  36. SIGNIS Statement: Oranges and Sunshine
  37. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March/April 2011
  38. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlinale 2011 Special Edition
  39. SIGNIS Statement: The Rite
  40. SIGNIS Statement: Brighton Rock
  41. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2011
  42. Out Of The Silence
  43. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2010
  44. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October/November 2010
  45. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2010
  46. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Summer 2010
  47. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2010 Special Edition
  48. SIGNIS Statement: "Des hommes et des dieux" (Of Gods and Men)
  49. SIGNIS Film Reviews: April/May 2010
  50. SIGNIS Statement: Agora
  51. SIGNIS Statement: The Calling
  52. SIGNIS Statement: Lourdes
  53. SIGNIS Statement: No Greater Love
  54. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2010 Special Edition
  55. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January/February 2010
  56. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October/November/December 2009
  57. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Summer 2009
  58. Antichrist: An Essay/Review
  59. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2009 Special Edition
  60. SIGNIS Statement: Angels and Demons
  61. SIGNIS Film Reviews: April 2009
  62. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March 2009
  63. SIGNIS Statement: Religulous
  64. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2009 Special Edition
  65. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February 2009
  66. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2009
  67. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2008
  68. The Church in Transition: Doubt
  69. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October-November 2008
  70. SIGNIS Statement: Brideshead Revisited and its Catholicism
  71. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2008
  72. SIGNIS Film reviews: August 2008
  73. SIGNIS Statement: The X-Files: I Want to Believe
  74. SIGNIS Film Reviews: July 2008
  75. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June 2008
  76. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2008 Special Edition
  77. SIGNIS Films Reviews: April 2008
  78. SIGNIS Film Reviews: March 2008
  79. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Berlin 2008 Special Edition
  80. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February 2008
  81. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2008
  82. SIGNIS Statement: The Golden Compass
  83. SIGNIS Film Reviews: November 2007
  84. SIGNIS Statement: Elizabeth - The Golden Age
  85. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October 2007
  86. SIGNIS Films Reviews: August/September 2007
  87. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June-July 2007
  88. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
  89. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2007 Special Edition
  90. SIGNIS Film Reviews: May 2007
  91. SIGNIS Film Reviews: April 2007
  92. SIGNIS Film Reviews: February/March 2007
  93. Deliver Us from Evil: SIGNIS Statement
  94. SIGNIS Film Reviews: January 2007
  95. SIGNIS Film Reviews: December 2006
  96. SIGNIS Film Reviews: November 2006
  97. The Nativity Story
  98. SIGNIS Film Reviews: October 2006
  99. SIGNIS Film Reviews: September 2006
  100. SIGNIS Film Reviews: August 2006
  101. SIGNIS Film Reviews: June/July 2006
  102. SIGNIS Film Reviews: Cannes 2006 Special Edition
  103. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, MARCH 2006, SUPPLEMENT
  104. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, MARCH 2006
  105. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, FEBRUARY 2006
  106. SIGNIS FILM REVIEWS, JANUARY 2006

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix

(JPEG) (UK, 2007, d. David Yates)

This is Harry Potter time. With the release of the last book in the series (and sales of millions) and the fifth film in the series, Harry Potter is a worldwide phenomenon.

Six years ago, when the first film came out, there was a great deal of heated discussion. Children and adults who were content to move into a fantasy world that looked at times a little like ours but was vastly different enjoyed the opportunity to make believe. What if...? On the other hand, a number of fervently religious people were alarmed at the words ‘magic’ and ‘spells’ and ‘wizard’ and interpreted the story as being against some of the literal injunctions of the Old Testament.

We hope that this discussion has been resolved, realising that J.K.Rowling was just inventing a world that was another fairy tale place with some adolescent epic touches. This is not a world to be taken literally. It is more like the imaginative world that J.R.R. Tolkein invented for the Lord of the Rings or that George Lucas invented for the Star Wars series. In fact, it is a useful comparison to make between Harry Potter and Frodo as well as with Luke Skywalker. They are young heroes who bear some of the burdens of evil in the world and receive a mission to combat evil.

This mission is becoming clearer as the books and the films continue. Harry started as a young boy. We have seen how he has changed as he moved through the early years of adolescence. Last time, Harry came face to face with the personification of evil, someone who had chosen to ‘go over to the dark side’, Voldemort. This film is literally darker as Voldemort now moves in on Harry to create an evil world. Harry has to draw on inner resources to be able to live up to his mission.

This time he has the support of his parents’ friends, the Order of the Phoenix (with its name of hope for rising again) and of his godfather, Sirrius Black. He also has to learn that he is not alone and rely on the support of Ron and Hermione (even if it means listening to lectures from Hermione).

This is a film for adolescent audiences. The classification is 12A or its equivalent which means that parents have to decide whether they want their younger children to see the film. If young children have started with the other books and films then they will know what to expect. Otherwise it could be puzzling and frightening.

Most of the familiar cast have returned, even if some of them have only a few moments. Adults will regret that there is not more of Emma Thompson, Maggie Smith and Robbie Coltrane. However, there is a new character who leaps off the screen at us as she tries to control Hogwarts and impose her kind of order. This is Dolores Umbridge, sent by the ministry to correct what are considered Dumbledore’s mistakes. She flounces around in pinks and mauves completely self-satisfied. Imelda Staunton gives a wonderful performance.

There are plenty of special effects that are amazing to watch, a delight that technology can create so much magic.

This is a review of the film, not the book - readers always find that the filmmakers have left out characters and incidents that they really wanted to see. But, as a Harry Potter film, the Order of the Phoenix should satisfy.

Peter Malone

print the article