print the article

Related articles
  1. Australasian Catholic Press Association : Awards for Excellence 2016
  2. Pope asks journalists to be professional and to respect human dignity
  3. International Day for Universal Access to Information
  4. The Ethical Journalism Network (EJN)
  5. Protecting threatened Journalists: the Journalists-in-Residence Programme
  6. Interview of the new CNS editor in chief
  7. AMECEA social communications department acquires tablets for online correspondents
  8. Burundian journalist receives the Peter Mackler Prize
  9. Register for the European Media Freedom Conference
  10. Tanzanian media professionals asked to be more compassionate
  11. RSF launches its campaign “Some wins don’t deserve medals”
  12. 2016 International Press Freedom Awards
  13. Malawian journalists must report on resilience policies
  14. Spheres: Journal for Digital Cultures
  15. UNESCO workshop: Inform, Engage, Investigate: Media and humanitarians in crisis situations
  16. RSF calls on Maldives to stop dismantling critical media
  17. Journalism in Conflict and Post-Conflict Conditions: Worldwide Perspectives
  18. CBC News programmes on Human Rights wins CJF Jackman Award for Excellence in Journalism
  19. Catholic Relief Services (CRS) Promoting Investigative journalism
  20. Journalists in Indonesia told to be messengers of peace
  21. Manipur to miss newspapers for month as agency is forced shut
  22. The Digital News Report 2016
  23. The use of drones in journalism
  24. RSF report on Syrian journalists
  25. 25 June 2016 – 4th edition of the #ImpactJournalism Day
  26. Reform of the Libyan media sector
  27. Scholarship for journalists from countries in crisis or at war
  28. IWMF Announces The 2016 Courage In Journalism Award Winners
  29. Radio journalist received award for best Filipino media practicioner
  30. Achievement Award to Tanzanian woman journalist
  31. Defending freedom of the press in Pakistan
  32. Media and journalism in Peace Work
  33. Online reporting: Telling Africa’s story on the web
  34. New network to promote African women
  35. "Poor journalism" is the biggest threat to media freedom
  36. World Press Freedom Day: SIGNIS Statement
  37. AMARC celebrates World Press Freedom Day 2016
  38. The African Free Press newspaper
  39. The 2016 World Press Freedom Index
  40. Empowering people through citizen journalism
  41. The good Sheperd: new journal of Pastoral Theology
  42. South Sudanese media are concerned about freedom of expression
  43. Bangladesh’s Catholic weekly turns 75
  44. Media professionals dedicated to raising gender awareness in China
  45. Korean Catholic weekly to launch e-newspaper
  46. Indian bishop urges media to uphold spiritual values, integrity
  47. Violence against female journalists
  48. Scholarships for Journalists
  49. Zambian Church urges Catholic media to be non-partisan on elections
  50. Archbishop Odama calls on the media to be proactive to ensure peaceful general elections
  51. Give Journalists freedom for South Sudan to grow, says Bishop Santo
  52. New edition of safety guide for journalists in high-risk environments
  53. New presidential decree to support media freedom in Afghanistan
  54. US presidential election: a rocky road for journalists
  55. UEC Chairman calls on the media to be proactive to ensure peaceful 2016 general elections
  56. Engaged journalism at Journalism Schools
  57. Indonesian Catholic weekly celebrates 70 years
  58. SOS Media Burundi
  59. Supporters of slain Sri Lankan journalist call for justice
  60. Good journalism vital for democracy, says Ecuadorian President
  61. What is soft censorship today? A report on the press in Macedonia
  62. Media leaders conference on Safety of journalists
  63. Paulines Publications opens new centre in Nairobi
  64. Reporters Without Borders publishes 2015 Round-up
  65. 10th anniversary of Agahi, the first weekly Catholic magazine in Urdu
  66. Open Earth: The beginning of global GeoJournalism
  67. Radio and newspaper ban make social media first choice for news in Burundi
  68. MISA awards journalists for excellence in reporting on children’s rights
  69. Kerala Jesuits publish new magazine to encourage thinking
  70. The Tablet, the 175-year British catholic journal.
  71. Kenyan women ’ignored’ in local media
  72. Professional and citizen journalism: a not so evident relationship
  73. Japanese newspaper readers help Catholic priest to provide education in rural Cambodia
  74. Floods stop publication of century-old Indian newspaper
  75. Catholic Church in Ethiopia organises media workshop on Laudato sì
  76. The 2015 Titus Brandsma Media Awards
  77. The fourth World Journalism Education Congress
  78. Media house attacked over derogatory cartoon in India
  79. National Geographic magazine’s cover story reveals Mary’s appeal
  80. In times of trouble: how media codes strengthen free expression
  81. CPJ honours Ethiopian journalists for their courage
  82. ’’Special Fund for Media Development’’ in Africa to be set up
  83. Women not portrayed equally by news media
  84. Indigenous journalists are changing the news in Saskatchewan
  85. Uganda Episcopal Conference held training for journalists before Papal visit
  86. Ethiopian journalists asked to promote care and protection of the environment
  87. Pacific media urged to promote gender equality
  88. Research: How Europe’s newspapers reported the migration crisis
  89. Indian newspapers protest against Assam Rifles with blank front pages
  90. Indonesia still obstructs foreign media in Papua
  91. Reporters on the Borders Network
  92. Call for responsible journalism in Kenya for Papal’s visit
  93. Media restrictions on Australia’s asylum seeker policy
  94. Catholic press struggles to earn trust in Australia
  95. Consolidating Peace Journalism through radio in Uganda
  96. New online publication: journal for religion, film and media
  97. International Federation of Journalists has a new general secretary
  98. Is journalism under threat?
  99. A new movement for ethical journalism is needed
  100. The rise of popular factual television in the Asia-Pacific region
  101. Global campaign to end impunity for crimes against journalists
  102. UCAN reporter recognized with environmental journalism award
  103. Media pluralism in danger: Monitoring Media Ownership in Colombia
  104. Pictures, refugees and a Jesuit photographer
  105. “In the eyes of the other”: photographic collection of Salesian Missions in Ecuador
  106. Cartoonists, media and ethics in Myanmar
  107. Press councils from South East Europe gather to discuss media ethics
  108. Bangladesh criticized for impunity over blogger murders
  109. Catholic development commission trains journalists on climate resilient policies in Malawi
  110. The literature Nobel Prize goes to a journalist
  111. The media’s role in fostering interfaith ties in Indonesia
  112. Catholic journalists seek greater impact in northern India
  113. Sri Lanka : The Gnanartha Pradeepaya celebrates its 150th birthday
  114. China: Pope Francis and Xi Jinping’s US trip media coverage
  115. Italy : The slow demise of Catholic magazines
  116. Wazala - a new Christian press agency in the Middle East
  117. Australasian Catholic Press Association celebrated 60th Anniversary
  118. Philippines : Bishop lauds arrest of environmental journalist’s alleged killers
  119. US : Papal Visit and Comprehensive media coverage
  120. US : Chicago archdiocese appointed Commonweal editor as new director of media
  121. Malaysia : Catholic newspaper and self censorship
  122. Liberia: Catholic archdiocese launches media programme in schools
  123. Standards of journalism education
  124. SIGNIS Asia reflects on journalism
  125. Philadelphia: 200 journalists attend seminar on Pope Francis
  126. 2015 Egan Journalism Fellowship Calls for Applications
  127. SIGNIS Services Rome Presents the Reporter Kit
  128. IWMF Launches the Howard G. Buffett Fund for Women Journalists

Catholic press struggles to earn trust in Australia

Brussels, Richmond, November 6th, 2015 (SIGNIS/ Tim Wallace/Eureka Street). In September 2015, Australia’s longest-running weekly newspaper, The Record, won a Design Excellence award. It was, however, somewhat belated recognition for the Perth Catholic newspaper, established in 1874, from its peers in the Australasian Catholic Press Association. The last edition of the paper rolled off the presses in July.

The decision to close down the 140-year-old weekly apparently came after a five-month review and many years of significant losses as the newspaper’s subscriber base, and advertising, dwindled. That it survived as long as it did was perhaps testament both to the previous archbishop’s preparedness to subsidise it to the tune of several hundred thousand dollars a year, the dedication of its overworked staff, and the devotion of its ageing readership, many of whom bought it out as much out of a sense of religious duty than interest in its content, which was of variable quality.

There had in the preceding decade been other reviews and plans hatched to check the newspaper’s decline, including one ambitious idea to turn the paper into a freebie and emulate the business model of suburban press. What the newspaper never really had was a coherent strategy to transition online, leveraging its established brand, content and capabilities to connect with a wider audience. A monthly magazine available in print and ’a user-friendly, engaging and interactive online format’ is apparently what the archdiocese now plans in its stead.

With the demise of The Record, the competition for the claim of Australia’s best Catholic weekly newspaper has narrowed to a field of two, Brisbane’s Catholic Leader and Sydney’s Catholic Weekly. Only time will tell if those two publications can avoid the fate of the rest of their fellow diocesan press operations, but in maintaining viability they face more than just navigating the harsh winds of technological and demographic change.

The antagonisms facing the Catholic press are complex

At the heart of press operations funded by the institutional church are some problematic contradictions about the differing needs of stakeholders. All media operations deal with internal antagonisms, of course. In the secular press it is jokingly known as the division between church and state – between the journalistic pursuit of news without fear or favour and the pressure to skew content toward advertising markets in general or certain advertisers in particular. No man can serve two masters, according of the good book, but any media operation dependent on both reader subscriptions and advertising revenue must do exactly that.

The antagonisms facing the Catholic press are more complex, reflecting the nature of the institution it serves. Though to outsiders the Church can seem monolithic, with a power structure rooted in medieval aristocracy, in practice its politics are more byzantine. Obviously there is the ecclesiastical authority of bishops, each a prince of his own fiefdom, with control over the purse strings and the power to make or break career prospects. There are the professional bureaucracies administering the Church’s sizeable operations in, for example, education and healthcare, with the natural bureaucratic preference for reportage that blandly replicates the press release. There are the idiosyncratic sensitivities of parish priests, who can wield an iron grip over a newspaper’s distribution and promotion in their own territory because, say, they are deeply offended it does not capitalise every word associated with religion.

How to get an interesting relevant newspaper in the Church

Appeasing both clerical and bureaucratic interests poses a considerable hurdle to producing an interesting, relevant newspaper. Add to the negotiation the raw differences between progressive and conservative tendencies within clergy and laity, with what one camp esteems as editorial heroism being reviled by the other. It is possible to produce journalism that satisfies both groups – take, for example the work of John Allen, the long-time Vatican correspondent of the National Catholic Reporter, a US title regarded as theologically liberal, whose reportage was also held in high regard by conservatives. But what distinguished Allen’s work was the epitome of good journalism – a rigorous adherence to accuracy, fairness and balance along with a deep understanding of his subject – with a scope unencumbered by the pettier considerations of institutional politics.

Doing the same within diocesan-owned press, where the bishop is the publisher, is harder. Along with all the above tensions are existential questions over the proper function of a Catholic newspaper. Does it exist to report news or proclaim the good news, acting primarily as instrument of evangelisation? Should it seek to provide a perspective on the big issues, covering global and national news, or devote itself to reflecting the life of the local community, covering parish fetes, ordinations, official appointments, obituaries and the like?

Certain compromises have been glaringly evident. It would be difficult to cite one official Church publication in Australia that has, for example, done more than a perfunctory job in covering the issue of clerical sex abuse. Generally the issue has been politely avoided, aside from endorsement of the official line. For ordinary church-goers the deep disconnect between the coverage of the issue between their own religious and the secular media must be bewildering, feeding the very feelings of embattlement and persecution that Cardinal George Pell conceded to the royal commission had contributed to the Church’s institutional failure to face up to the problem.

Given the general acknowledgement of the effect the sex-abuse crisis has had on mass attendance and collection-plate contributions, it would be hard to conclude there has not also been a hit on the credibility of the Catholic press. Maintaining relevance in the light of experiences that show trust must be earned rather than assumed will take more than technical capability, slick headlines or social media sharing buttons.


print the article